拉夫纳赫曼·巴尔·以撒 驳道:两位所争的是大海洁与不洁一层,安息日一层何曾听说他们相争?他自解两条巴拉伊塔之相违:禁的一条指人泡在水里不出来,显是为医治;许的一条指人不久留。
-
你说他们所争的是地中海论洁与不洁的分位,论安息日一层,你何曾听见他们相争呢?
Say that they disagree over the status of the Mediterranean Sea with regard to impurity and purity, but with regard to Shabbat did you hear that they disagree?
-
倒不如说,拉夫纳赫曼·巴尔·以撒 说:两条 《巴拉伊塔》 相违之处并不难解。
Rather, Rav Naḥman bar Yitzḥak said: The contradiction between the two baraitot is not difficult.
-
这一条禁人在地中海里洗浴的 《巴拉伊塔》,是指人泡在水里不出来、因而显明他在地中海里洗浴是为着医治的。
This baraita, which prohibits bathing in the Mediterranean, is referring to a case where one remained in the water and thereby indicated that he bathed in the Mediterranean for its curative effects.
-
那一条许人洗浴的 《巴拉伊塔》,是指人不在水里久留、因而显明他在地中海里洗浴不是为医治的。
That baraita, which permits bathing, is referring to a case where one did not remain in the water, and thereby indicated that he bathed in the Mediterranean for non-medical purposes.